Career Money
Quick Answer
Should you wait for a promotion or change jobs for a raise? Wait only when your employer can give you three concrete things: specific criteria, a named decision-maker or clearly defined approval path, and a realistic decision date. Otherwise, test the market. A written external offer gives you a known salary today. A possible promotion must be evaluated by both its expected size and the probability that it happens on time.
The decision rule this guide builds toward: waiting is reasonable only when three things are concrete, the criteria, the approver, and the decision date. If any one of them is missing or vague, that absence is itself useful information, not a reason to keep waiting quietly.
At a Glance
| Factor | Wait for Promotion | Change Jobs |
|---|---|---|
| Pay certainty | Low until approved and documented | High once a written offer exists |
| Timing | Depends on review cycles, budgets, and open roles | Depends on your search and the hiring timeline |
| Main data point | Raise size among employees who were actually promoted | Pay growth among workers who changed employers |
| Benefits and vesting | Usually preserved | May reset or change |
| Environment risk | Usually a more familiar manager, culture, and internal systems, though a promotion can still mean a new team or manager | New manager, workload, culture, and stability |
| Strongest evidence you can gather | Specific criteria, a named approver, a decision date | A written offer with full compensation terms |
Who This Applies To
This guide is for people who are already doing well enough that a promotion is plausible, and who could realistically get interviews elsewhere if they looked. If neither is true yet, the more useful step is building toward one of those two positions, not choosing between them.
This Isn’t the Right Guide If
- You’re deciding whether to accept one specific offer already in hand; see how to compare two job offers instead
- You’re trying to size how big a raise needs to be before switching makes sense at all; see what percentage raise is worth changing jobs for
- You’re unhappy enough that you’d leave regardless of the pay difference; that’s a more personal decision this guide doesn’t try to resolve
What the Data Actually Shows
Every figure below is presented with its source, its date, and what it does and doesn’t measure. None of these numbers is a guarantee for your specific job, industry, or employer.
Job switchers vs. job stayers
In its June 2026 National Employment Report, ADP reported median annual pay growth of 6.6% for job-changers and 4.4% for job-stayers, a gap of 2.2 percentage points. ADP’s measure tracks matched individual workers’ actual year-over-year pay changes; it is not a survey of job offers, and it is not the typical percentage increase you’d see written into a specific offer letter. The category can include workers who received large increases, made lateral moves, or accepted lower pay for other reasons, all averaged together.
A separate measure, the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta’s Wage Growth Tracker, uses a different methodology (median hourly wage growth from Current Population Survey microdata). Its June 2026 reading showed a narrower gap: 4.1% for people changing jobs versus 3.4% for people who didn’t, a difference of 0.7 percentage points. The two series don’t have to agree exactly, since they sample different populations and calculate pay differently, but both point the same direction: switching still tends to pay more on average, though the advantage is narrower than it was during the unusually strong job-switching market of a few years ago, and it varies a lot by industry.
June 2026 Data Snapshot, Checked August 1, 2026
The figures above are a June 2026 reading, the most recent available as of this guide’s last update. ADP and the Atlanta Fed both publish monthly; ADP’s next National Employment Report is scheduled for August 5, 2026. Source update policy: the wage-growth figures on this page are reviewed quarterly, or sooner if the job-changer premium shifts materially. Verify the linked ADP and Atlanta Fed sources directly if you’re reading this after that date.
The typical promotion raise
Mercer’s October 2025 QuickPulse U.S. Compensation Planning Survey (over 1,000 U.S. organizations) found employers planned to promote around 9% of their workforce in 2026, down from 10% in 2025, with an average pay increase of 8.7% for a one-level promotion. That same survey projected a 3.2% average merit increase and a 3.5% average total increase for 2026.
A later Mercer QuickPulse U.S. Compensation Planning Survey update on actual 2026 increases, based on 756 organizations, found what employers actually paid came in slightly under those projections: a 3.1% mean merit increase and a 3.4% mean total increase. Both figures are organization-level averages, not a guaranteed raise for any individual employee, and salary-increase budgets in general are not the same thing as what one specific person receives.
Three Different Things, Often Confused
Promotion: a move to a higher level, title, or scope of responsibility. It may or may not come with a meaningful pay increase. Merit raise: a pay increase tied to performance that doesn’t necessarily change your title or level. External move: a move to a different employer, which can be a genuine step up, a lateral move, or occasionally a pay cut, depending on the specific offer.
Why These Two Numbers Aren’t Directly Comparable
It’s tempting to compare ADP’s 6.6% annual pay-growth figure for job-changers with Mercer’s 8.7% average planned promotion increase and conclude promotions win. That comparison doesn’t hold up for three reasons.
They measure different things. The job-changer figure is a pay-growth rate across everyone who changed employers recently, including lateral moves. The promotion figure is the raise size only among people who were actually promoted. It’s not the same population or the same question.
One becomes knowable the moment you have it in writing; the other doesn’t. A written external offer tells you your new pay immediately. A promotion depends on budget, timing, your manager’s advocacy, and whether a role opens up or gets created. A written offer provides a known salary; starting a search does not by itself guarantee a faster or larger raise, since the search itself takes time and may not produce an offer at all.
Switching resets things a promotion usually doesn’t. A new employer may mean a new PTO accrual clock, a new vesting schedule for any retirement match or equity, or a waiting period before benefits start. A promotion raise is generally calculated from your current base pay, depending on the employer’s compensation structure; whether it’s combined with a separate merit increase in the same year, or replaces it, depends entirely on your employer’s specific policy and timing, not a universal rule.
The Real Trade-offs Beyond the Raw Percentage
Career capital and compounding. Whether staying builds real capability or just tenure is specific to your actual job, not something a survey average can answer. Either raise compounds on top of your base for every future percentage-based increase, so the path that compounds for more years from a higher starting point can end up ahead even if its first bump was smaller, or vice versa. The worked example below shows this mechanic directly.
The promotion you’re promised isn’t the promotion you’ll get. “You’re next in line” isn’t a commitment. A verbal timeline can change if budgets, organizational structure, or management change.
A new job carries its own uncertainty. Culture, workload, and stability are unknowns until you’re actually there. A larger number on paper doesn’t help if the role turns out to be a worse fit.
A lateral move isn’t automatically wasted. A move that raises pay without immediately changing your title or level can still expand your skills, scope, industry access, or future promotion path. Evaluate it on those terms, not just the title change.
Reference and reputation risk. Leaving sooner than expected may affect the reference you receive later, and a pattern of very short tenures may require explanation in future interviews, though how much this matters varies a lot by industry and seniority.
A Framework for Deciding
Answer these before comparing raw numbers:
- Has your employer actually promoted people in your position recently, on a knowable timeline? If yes, you have real data about your own odds. If no one in your role has been promoted in years, treat “you’re next” skeptically.
- Is the promotion raise close to the market figures above, or does your employer typically under- or over-pay for promotions? Some employers give a title change with minimal pay movement, sometimes called a dry promotion.
- Would you be leaving for a genuine step up in scope, or a lateral move with a bigger number attached? Both can be reasonable, but they’re different decisions.
- What do you lose by switching? Vesting, accrued PTO, and relationship capital with people who could vouch for you later all have real value a base-salary comparison won’t show.
- How much does the uncertainty itself cost you? If you can’t tolerate an open-ended wait, that’s a legitimate reason to prioritize the more certain path, even if the averages point the other way.
A more complete comparison: estimate cumulative compensation over the same time period for three outcomes: the external-offer path, the promotion path, and the no-promotion path. Weight the two stay outcomes by your own estimated probability of being promoted by the target date, then compare that expected total with the written offer. Add vesting, bonuses, benefits, signing bonuses, and role-quality differences separately. This is a decision framework, not a precise forecast, since you’re supplying the probability estimate yourself, based on how concrete your employer’s answer actually was.
An Illustrative Comparison
The tables below use explicitly stated assumptions to illustrate the mechanics of the decision, not to predict an individual outcome. Real outcomes depend on your specific offer, your specific promotion, and factors this model doesn’t capture.
Assumptions: both paths start at $70,000. Path A receives a hypothetical 10% external offer, an illustrative figure, not an ADP estimate. Path B receives Mercer’s 8.7% average planned one-level promotion increase in the stated year. Both paths otherwise receive a 3.2% annual merit increase, matching Mercer’s own October 2025 projected merit figure, and the promotion replaces that year’s merit increase rather than stacking with it, since whether the two combine depends on your employer’s specific policy. The model excludes bonuses, equity, signing bonuses, benefits differences, taxes, inflation, and any employment gap. Figures are rounded to the nearest dollar.
Scenario 1: The Promotion Arrives on Time (Year 2)
| Year | Path A: Switch Now | Path B: Wait, Promotion Lands Year 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Year 0 (start) | $70,000 | $70,000 |
| Year 1 | $77,000 (10% offer) | $72,240 (3.2% merit) |
| Year 2 | $79,464 (3.2% merit) | $78,525 (8.7% promotion) |
| Year 3 | $82,007 (3.2% merit) | $81,038 (3.2% merit) |
Cumulative base pay, Years 1-3: Path A = $238,471; Path B = $231,803; difference = about $6,668 before taxes and excluded benefits.
Even with the promotion arriving exactly on schedule, Path A remains ahead under these assumptions, because the external offer is larger than the promotion increase and takes effect one year earlier. If both salaries then receive the same percentage increases afterward, Path B does not close that gap without another larger raise or promotion. This example doesn’t prove that switching always wins; it shows why the actual written offer and its timing matter more than the national averages on their own.
Scenario 2: The Promotion Is Delayed to Year 4
| Year | Path A: Switch Now | Path B: Wait, Promotion Delayed to Year 4 |
|---|---|---|
| Year 0 (start) | $70,000 | $70,000 |
| Year 1 | $77,000 | $72,240 |
| Year 2 | $79,464 | $74,552 |
| Year 3 | $82,007 | $76,937 |
| Year 4 | $84,631 | $83,631 (8.7% promotion) |
Cumulative base pay, Years 1-4: Path A = $323,102; Path B = $307,360; difference = about $15,742 before taxes and excluded benefits.
When the promotion is delayed to Year 4, the cumulative cost of waiting grows further. Under these assumptions, Path B remains below Path A even after the promotion lands, because both paths are assumed to receive the same annual increases afterward. A later promotion would need to be larger than 8.7%, or followed by faster future raises, to close a gap this size.
The lesson isn’t which column wins. It’s that the answer depends entirely on one thing you don’t control with certainty: when, or whether, the promotion actually happens. That’s the variable worth interrogating honestly, using the framework above, not the published averages on their own.
What to Actually Ask
Before deciding, ask your manager directly, in words close to these:
“I’m interested in progressing to [role]. What specific results or responsibilities would I need to demonstrate, who approves the promotion, and which review cycle could realistically include the decision?”
Follow-up: “Can we document those criteria and set a date to check back on progress?”
A vague “you’re doing great, we’ll see” is meaningfully different from a specific criteria list and a stated review cycle. If you can’t get a concrete answer after directly asking, that’s useful information about how predictable this path actually is at your employer.
If you do have a competing offer, run it through a full comparison, not just the base salary line:
Offer Comparison Checklist
- ✓ Base salary and target bonus
- ✓ Historical bonus payout, not just the target
- ✓ Signing bonus and its clawback terms
- ✓ Equity and its vesting schedule
- ✓ Retirement match and its vesting schedule
- ✓ Healthcare premiums and deductibles
- ✓ Paid leave and any benefits waiting period
- ✓ Commute or relocation cost
- ✓ Title, level, and actual job scope
- ✓ Job stability and severance terms
- ✓ Value of unvested compensation you would forfeit by leaving
- ✓ Expected weekly working hours or on-call obligations
For the full version of this comparison, see how to compare two job offers. For what to do once a raise or promotion actually lands, see what to do with a raise, and for the total-compensation math behind any of these numbers, see salary vs. total compensation.
Common Mistakes
Treating “I’m Overdue” as a Plan
Being overdue doesn’t create budget or an open role. Without a direct conversation about criteria and timeline, you have a hope, not a plan.
Assuming Every Promotion Includes a Market-Level Raise
Confirm the title, salary, bonus target, responsibilities, and effective date before accepting expanded duties. A title change with minimal pay movement, sometimes called a dry promotion, can leave you doing higher-level work below that role’s market range.
Comparing Only Base Salary
A new offer’s total compensation, bonus structure, retirement match, and benefits can differ substantially from its headline base number. Use the checklist above before comparing any specific offer.
Ignoring What You’d Give Up
Unvested equity, an accrued PTO balance, and internal reputation all have real value. Calculate what you’re leaving on the table, not just what you’d gain.
Never Actually Asking
Many people choose between waiting quietly and quitting without warning, without ever asking their manager directly about timeline and criteria. That conversation alone often changes the calculation.
Should You Wait for a Promotion or Change Jobs: The Decision Rule
Wait only when you have specific promotion criteria, a named decision-maker, and a decision date close enough to justify the pay you might be forgoing in the meantime. Otherwise, test the market, without assuming that starting a search obligates you to leave.
Compare a written external offer against the probability-adjusted value of waiting, including benefits, vesting, role quality, and career scope, not just the two headline percentages. You can decline an external offer once you have it. Use it as leverage in a promotion conversation only if you’re genuinely prepared to accept it should your employer say no or start treating your search as a retention risk rather than a negotiating point.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do job switchers really earn more than people who stay?
On average, yes, though the gap has narrowed substantially since 2022, when ADP reported job-changer annual pay growth of 16.1%. ADP reported a 2.2-percentage-point gap in June 2026; the Atlanta Fed’s separately-calculated tracker showed a narrower 0.7-point gap the same month. Both are economy-wide averages; your specific industry and role may differ.
What’s a normal raise for a promotion?
Mercer’s October 2025 survey found employers planned an average 8.7% increase for a one-level promotion in 2026. Actual promotion raises vary by employer, industry, and how many levels you’re moving up, and some “promotions” come with little to no pay change.
How long should I wait for a promised promotion?
There’s no universal number of months. Ask for a specific decision date tied to your employer’s normal budget or review cycle. If that date passes without documented criteria or a new decision point, treat it as a signal to test the external market rather than accepting another open-ended promise.
How often should I expect to get promoted?
There’s no universal timeline. Employers surveyed for 2026 planned to promote roughly 9% of their workforce on average, but that figure spans very different promotion cultures and doesn’t tell you your own odds. Ask your manager directly about criteria and typical timing in your specific role.
Is it disloyal to look for other jobs while hoping for a promotion?
Job searching while employed is common and not inherently dishonest, but consider your specific workplace culture, any contractual restrictions, and whether an active search could affect an in-progress promotion conversation before deciding how openly to run both processes at once.
Should I use a competing offer to negotiate a promotion?
It can work, but it carries real risk: some employers respond well to a credible competing offer, while others treat it as a sign you’re already leaving. Only use an offer as leverage if you’re genuinely prepared to accept it if the conversation doesn’t go your way, since how it tends to land depends heavily on your specific manager and company culture.
Sources and Methodology
Pay-growth figures come from ADP’s National Employment Report (payroll data on a matched cohort of workers, tracked year-over-year) and the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta’s Wage Growth Tracker (a separate methodology based on Current Population Survey microdata). Promotion and merit-increase figures come from Mercer’s QuickPulse U.S. Compensation Planning Survey, October 2025 (projections) and its 2026 update on actual increases delivered. All figures are aggregate averages, not individual predictions. The illustrative comparison in this guide uses a hypothetical external offer, Mercer’s published average planned promotion increase, and an explicitly stated annual-raise assumption. These inputs demonstrate the mechanics of timing and compounding; they are not predictions for an individual reader’s offer or promotion.
ADP National Employment Report, June 2026
ADP National Employment Report, August 2022 (historical comparison)
Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, Wage Growth Tracker
Mercer, October 2025 QuickPulse U.S. Compensation Planning Survey
Mercer, QuickPulse U.S. Compensation Planning Survey, actual 2026 increase results
Data checked August 1, 2026. Wage-growth figures are reviewed quarterly, or sooner if the job-changer premium shifts materially; promotion figures are reviewed when a new Mercer Compensation Planning Survey is released.
Educational content only. This guide describes published survey averages and a general decision framework; it does not guarantee a specific raise, promotion, or timeline. Individual results vary based on employer, industry, negotiation, and factors outside this guide’s control.
Get money tips that actually help
Free weekly newsletter. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.